Hewlett-Packard Lawsuit Against Brevard Clerk of Court Dismissed

Scott Ellis

ORLANDO, Florida -- Earlier today, U.S. District Judge Charlene Edwards Honeywell approved a U.S. Magistrate Judge’s Report and Recommendation that Hewlett-Packard Financial Service’s lawsuit against the current Brevard County Clerk of the Circuit Court, Scott Ellis, for non-payment of a $6.1 million loan be dismissed on jurisdictional grounds.  The dismissal allows Hewlett-Packard to refile its action in Florida state court. 


Former Brevard County Clerk of Court Mitch Needelman entered into the $6.1 million loan after losing the primary election in 2012 to fulfill the funding of a scanning contract that is tied to the criminal case brought by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement against Needelman, his business partner Matt DuPree, and BlueGEM CEO Rose Harr.  BlueGEM was a direct recipient of $5.7 million of the loan.   

Ellis continues to assert that the loan done by Needelman, BlueGEM, Harr, and Hewlett-Packard was illegal and unconstitutional. Ellis reaffirmed that he would continue to defend that position should Hewlett-Packard refile its claim in state court.

Mitch Needelman

Hewlett-Packard also alleged in the lawsuit that Caruso, Swerbilow & Camerota, P.A., a Merritt Island, Florida law firm, engaged in  “professional malpractice, negligent misrepresentation, and breach of fiduciary duty” after the lawfirm had “provided a legal opinion letter verifying that the Clerk had the power and authority” to borrow funds to pay BlueGem for the scanning contract.   BlueGEM, and Harr were also parties to the suit. 

Brevard Times was the only news source to continue a series of in-depth investigative articles led by Charles Parker into this and related stories: 

 

RELATED STORIES:

Needelman: Ellis' "Complicated" Requests Delayed Release of Clerk Documents, BlueWare Contracts Jul 5, 2012

Contract Controversy Taints Florida Governor's Jobs Campaign July 10, 2012

Clerk of Court Sunshine Lawsuit Hearing Monday  July 21, 2012

Needelman Wins Partial Victory in Court Case Brought by Ellis July 23, 2012

$8.5 Million Brevard Clerk of Court Records Digitizing Underway  Oct. 17, 2012

Clerk's Attorney Refers Staffing Questions to BlueWare  Nov. 1, 2012

BlueWare Misses Clerk's Office Deadline  Nov. 7, 2012

UPDATE: Needelman and Company Owner Mum Regarding Digitizing Contract Nov. 15, 2012

DuPree Confirms BlueWare Scanning Readiness  Nov. 17, 2012

Charles Parker: Hey Mitch and Matt: How About Some Answers? December 4, 2012

Charles Parker: Divergent Views on Clerk's Contract Continue December 11, 2012

Former Clerk's Digitizing Contract Under More Scrutiny  Jan. 19, 2013

Economic Development Commission of Florida's Space Coast Subpoenaed By FDLE February 28, 2013

Charles Parker: BlueWare, Rose Harr, and Me  March 2, 2013

BlueWare Not Using Available Training Funds Mar. 15, 2013

Hewlett Packard Threatens Lawsuit Over BlueWare Debt Mar. 23, 2013

Brevard County Clerk of Court Files Suit Against BlueGem March 29, 2013

Details of Brevard Clerk of the Court Lawsuits Against BlueGem and RoseWare Emerge In Court Filings March 29, 2013

Space Coast Economic Incentives Make Florida Headlines  Apr. 1, 2013

BlueGem Counter-Sues Clerk's Office: Claims Ellis' "Ignorance"  May 5, 2013

Ellis and Hewlett-Packard Still At Odds Over Scanning Contract Loan Payments  June 2, 2013

Hewlett Packard Sues Brevard Clerk of Court For Disputed Scanning Contract Payments Jul 26, 2013

Former Brevard County Clerk of Court, Business Partner Arrested - Warrant Issued for Blueware CEO August 15, 2013

BlueWare CEO Turns Herself In August 16, 2013